Cincinnati Already Ran This Experiment Last Year

Joe Burrow is playing today.

That's worth saying plainly, because the word attached to him this week was questionable and that word does a lot of work it hasn't earned here. He tweaked his back in Week 1, colliding with Alex Anzalone while chasing a first down. He was limited Wednesday and Thursday, practiced in full on Friday, and Zac Taylor said he's good to go. Burrow's own version was blunter... if I'm not getting surgery, I'll be out there.

The designation is there because back tightness can feel fine on Friday and different on Sunday morning, and because Cincinnati has reasons to be careful with this particular quarterback that it wouldn't have with somebody else. It isn't a coin flip. It's a team covering itself.

But the tag did something useful before it resolved. It put a question in front of everyone that's worth answering regardless of who takes the first snap in Houston, because Burrow has missed sixteen games in the last three seasons and this will come up again. The question is what this offense becomes without him, and specifically what happens to Ja'Marr Chase, who is coming off two catches for twelve yards and has people wondering whether the problem was the quarterback at all.

Last season already answered most of it.

What actually happened to Chase against Tampa

Four targets in a game Cincinnati threw it 35 times. An eleven percent share for a receiver who has put up 23 targets in a single afternoon.

The number underneath it is the one that matters. Chase finished with 0.33 yards per route run, his lowest since November of 2023, and a 55.3 receiving grade. That's not a receiver getting open while his quarterback misses him. That's a receiver who wasn't thrown to and didn't do much on the routes where the chance existed.

Tampa built their plan to make that happen. Their corner said before the game that the focus was getting Chase on the ground after the catch, and what Chase does with the ball in his hands is the entire profile. Cincinnati looked at it, declined to force anything, and went to Gesicki and the backs. They scored 33 and won by six.

So there was no Burrow-Chase disconnect in the way people mean it. The two of them didn't misfire. The offense went elsewhere on purpose and it worked, which is a different thing and it changes what you'd expect this week. Taylor has said the plan is to get him more involved, which is what every coach says about a receiver coming off twelve yards, and is also probably true here because the cause was situational rather than structural.

The back is worth watching even though he's playing

Burrow missed nine games last season and seven in 2023. The 2025 season was defined by a Week 2 injury and a September surgery, which is a strange thing to be typing in the week of a Week 2 game where he's carrying an injury designation.

None of that makes the back worse than it is. What it means is that the organization will handle any flare-up with a caution it wouldn't apply to a quarterback with a clean history, and that the gap between playing and playing well is wider than usual. A back that tightens up doesn't announce itself with a cart. It shows up in how a quarterback steps into throws in the fourth quarter.

Cincinnati also elevated Josh Johnson from the practice squad as an emergency third quarterback this week. That's routine housekeeping, and it's also the kind of housekeeping teams do when they've thought about the branch they say they aren't worried about.

The Flacco question has an answer, and it's a loud one

Here's what surprised me when I went back.

When Flacco took over in 2025, Chase became the most targeted player in football. Not among Bengals. In the league. He had 107 targets over that stretch, twenty clear of any other player at any position, and turned them into 76 catches for 831 yards and five scores.

Flacco himself led the NFL in passing yards and touchdowns from Week 6 on, 1,254 and 11, with an 86.0 offensive grade that ranked fourth. At forty he threw for a career-high 470 yards in a game and became the oldest quarterback to put up 450 and four scores. The offense cleared 30 points in three of four games at one stretch, including back to back 38-point afternoons.

So if the worry is that a Flacco start would suppress Chase, the only evidence available says no, and it isn't close. Flacco fed him more than any quarterback in the league fed anybody.

That's the case and I think it holds. Here's why I'd stop short of calling it good news.

Cincinnati went 1-8 in those games

That's the number that reframes everything above it.

The 2025 Bengals without Burrow were 1-8. Flacco was throwing for 300 and 400 yards and Chase was seeing fifteen targets a game because Cincinnati was behind constantly and had no other way to play. The defense couldn't get a stop, the deficit arrived early, and the offense spent every second half dropping back because dropping back was all that was left.

Those are real numbers produced by a bad situation. It's the same mechanism that made Jared Goff look like the better quarterback in Buffalo on Thursday night... yardage piles up fastest when a team has been stripped of every other option. Chase's 107 targets are the receiver version of that.

Which brings up the part that matters for this season.

The reason it might not repeat is the thing Cincinnati fixed

Against Tampa the Bengals defense forced four fumbles, recovered all four, got four sacks, and scored a touchdown. That unit was a disaster a year ago, the front office spent the offseason on it, and for one Sunday the money looked like it worked.

If that holds even partially, Cincinnati plays with leads. A team with a lead throws less, runs more, and spreads it around. That's exactly the game they played last week, and it's exactly the game in which Chase caught two passes.

So the Flacco-means-Chase-eats argument quietly depends on Cincinnati being bad in the specific way it was bad last year. That target explosion was downstream of a defense that couldn't stop anyone. Take that away and you don't get the same offense, whoever is under center.

The uncomfortable version is that the healthiest season for the Bengals as a football team probably includes more afternoons like last Sunday, because that's what winning comfortably looks like on a roster this deep. Burrow, Chase, Higgins, Chase Brown, Gesicki, one football. When the defense hands you short fields, the ball has five places to go and no reason to force it anywhere.

What today is actually about

Not the quarterback question. That one's settled. The front.

Houston has Will Anderson Jr. and Danielle Hunter, who combined for 27 sacks last season, with Jadeveon Clowney and his 8.5 behind them. That's one of the better pass rushes in the league and it's walking into a game against a quarterback whose back tightened up five days ago.

The counterweight is that Cincinnati's line was outstanding in Week 1. One sack allowed, a 21.6 percent pressure rate that led the league, and Amarius Mims going 37 snaps at right tackle without giving up a pressure. If the line plays like that again, the back stays a footnote. If Houston gets home four or five times, it becomes the story of Cincinnati's season by Monday morning.

The Chase piece comes down to Derek Stingley Jr., which carries some history since the two were teammates at LSU. Burrow called him the best ball skills in the league at corner, which is the sort of thing quarterbacks say in press conferences and also happens to be defensible.

Stingley is coming off his own odd week. Buffalo went at him for four catches and 68 yards on six targets and he graded 46.1 in coverage, nowhere near his standard. Two of the best players at their positions, both arriving off the worst versions of themselves, on a Houston team that can't afford 0-2.

What I'm watching

How Burrow moves after the first real hit. Everything else about Cincinnati's afternoon runs through that, and it won't show up in the box score either way.

Whether Chase's route volume changes, not just his catches. The Week 1 problem lived in yards per route run, which means the routes were there and the ball wasn't. If the targets climb and that number doesn't, it's still the same issue wearing a better disguise.

And whether the defense shows up twice. One game of forcing four fumbles is a good Sunday. Two games of getting stops starts being a reason to think the shape of this team has changed, and that shape decides whether this offense throws 45 times a game or 30 for the rest of the year.

Previous
Previous

The Chiefs Found Their Skeleton Key... the Colts Are Still Working With One

Next
Next

Buffalo Won By Ten And It Was Never Close